Two of the most popular catering options we get asked about at Island Time are BBQ and Taco Bars.
Both are crowd-pleasers. Both are casual and fun. Both are scratch-made with real ingredients. So how do you choose?
Here’s a simple breakdown to help you figure out which one fits your event.
The Quick Comparison
| BBQ Catering | Taco Bar | |
| Vibe | Laid-back, smoky, Southern comfort | Fun, interactive, variety |
| Best for | Backyard parties, corporate events, weddings | Weddings, graduations, corporate lunches |
| Guest interaction | Buffet-style, self serve | Build-your-own, self serve buffet |
| Dietary flexibility | Some gluten free options available. | Gluten free and vegetarian options available! |
| Crowd size | Any | Any |
| Kids-friendly | Very | Very |
When to Choose BBQ Catering
BBQ catering in Rhode Island is the move when you want food that feels hearty, comforting, and impressive without being fussy.
It works especially well for:
- Backyard parties — nothing compliments a backyard summer event better than slow-smoked BBQ
- Corporate events and company picnics — easy to serve, easy to eat, zero complaints
- Outdoor weddings — rustic, relaxed, and memorable
- Large gatherings — BBQ holds well and feeds a crowd
At Island Time, our BBQ is slow-smoked over hickory logs with grass-fed beef, heritage-breed pork, and organic poultry. No shortcuts, no processed ingredients – just real BBQ done right.
When to Choose a Taco Bar
A taco bar is the right call when you want guests to be involved in the food experience. There’s something about building your own tacos that gets people excited and keeps the energy up. Taco bars offer a variety of flavors and toppings for everyone to enjoy!
It works especially well for:
- Graduation parties — fun, casual, and works for all age groups
- Banquet events — fresh flavors your team will crave
- Office lunches — easy to set up, quick to serve, satisfying for everyone
- Weddings with a relaxed vibe — memorable menus that stand out from the rest.
Our taco bars are scratch-made using our own recipes, from smoked and grilled proteins to fresh house-made sides, real guac, and all the fixings.
Still Can’t Decide?
Here’s a simple rule of thumb:
- If you want guests to sit back and enjoy → go BBQ
- If you want guests to get involved with the food → go taco bar
- If you want both → we can do that too
Some of our best events have combined a Taco Bar with BBQ elements. We’ll help you build a menu that works for your crowd, your venue, and your budget!
Ready to Plan Your Event?
Whether you go BBQ, taco bar, or a mix of both, Island Time Catering Co. makes it easy. Scratch-made food, stress-free service, and a team that actually cares about what goes on your plate.
Get in touch today and let’s start planning.
